Otto's Review - london Restaurants | Christoff

Otto's Restaurant: Where Alsatian Theatre Meets Gothic Romance

A hidden fine-dining sanctuary where tradition reigns supreme

My Honest Review

Atmosphere & Ambiance

Otto's occupies a fascinating space between old-world glamour and theatrical eccentricity. The venue scores an impressive 9.5/10 for sophistication while maintaining an intimate energy level of 3.5/10 – creating that coveted atmosphere of a private universe presided over by a spiritual host. The gothic drawing room aesthetic, complete with intimate booths, transforms dining into something approaching performance art. With a uniqueness score of 8.5/10, this isn't your typical London restaurant experience. The space feels deliberately idiosyncratic, designed for meaningful encounters rather than casual dining – reflected in its conversation-friendly score of 7.0/10 and experience depth rating of 9.0/10. It's romantic without being cliché, eccentric without being off-putting, and sophisticated without being stuffy. The wine sanctuary aspect adds another layer of charm, with the extensive cellar serving as both storage and stage for Otto's passionate wine presentations.

Food & Drink

The menu reads like a love letter to traditional Alsatian and French haute cuisine, anchored by Otto's signature duck press – a tableside theatre piece that's become the restaurant's claim to fame. The kitchen delivers generous portions that defy fine-dining stereotypes while maintaining haute cuisine standards, a refreshing approach in London's often precious dining scene. Standout dishes include lobster soufflé, expertly prepared steak tartare, foie gras pie, and snails served in marrow bone. The scallops in beurre blanc with caviar showcase technical precision, while the flaming crêpes Suzette provide a dramatic finale prepared tableside. This is pilgrimage-worthy cuisine for tradition-seekers, executed with the kind of old-school technique that's increasingly rare. The Alsatian influence sets Otto's apart from London's sea of French restaurants, offering diners a more specific regional focus that feels both authentic and distinctive.

Service & Experience

Otto's personal involvement elevates the service from professional to genuinely memorable. He guides guests through wine pairings with the enthusiasm of someone sharing family treasures, while the tableside duck press ceremony becomes a masterclass in theatrical dining. The service is described as discreet and polished, striking that difficult balance between attentive and intrusive. The personal service tag reflects Otto's hands-on approach – this isn't corporate hospitality but rather the passion project of someone who genuinely cares about each guest's experience. However, the restaurant requires phone-only reservations for the signature duck press experience, which may frustrate those accustomed to online booking systems.

Value for Money

At price level 4/4, Otto's sits firmly in London's fine-dining tier, but the value proposition extends beyond the plate. The extensive Alsatian and French wine cellar operates on fair cost-plus pricing, a refreshing approach that suggests genuine passion over profit maximization. Those generous portions mentioned earlier help justify the premium pricing, as does the theatrical tableside service that transforms dinner into entertainment. The experience depth score of 9.0/10 indicates you're paying for something genuinely memorable rather than just expensive ingredients. Wine cellar tours, tastings, and private dining options add value for those seeking special occasion experiences. While certainly not cheap, the combination of quality cuisine, personal service, and unique atmosphere positions Otto's as worthwhile for those seeking tradition and theatre in equal measure.

Insider Tips

Best Time to Visit

Book the Tuesday 6pm slot for maximum Otto interaction time – he'll have more opportunity to walk you through the wine cellar like a personal tour guide. The restaurant operates Tuesday-Friday for lunch (12pm-2pm) and Tuesday-Saturday for dinner (6pm-9:30pm), with Sundays and Mondays closed. Early evening slots likely offer the most theatrical experience.

What to Focus On

The signature duck press is essential – it's the restaurant's claim to fame and Otto's theatrical masterpiece. Don't miss the lobster soufflé or the foie gras pie for classic technique, and end with flaming crêpes Suzette for the full tableside theatre experience. Let Otto guide your wine selections from the extensive Alsatian and French cellar.

Christoff's Insider Tips

Phone-only reservations are required for the duck press experience – don't expect online booking. Request a wine cellar tour during your visit; Otto's passion for his collection is infectious and educational. The intimate booths offer the most romantic seating, while counter spots might provide better views of the tableside preparations.

The Final Verdict

Otto's Restaurant succeeds brilliantly at something increasingly rare in London's dining scene: genuine, uncompromising commitment to tradition without feeling like a museum piece. The combination of Otto's personal involvement, theatrical tableside service, and serious Alsatian cuisine creates an experience that scores 9.0/10 for depth and 8.5/10 for uniqueness. Yes, it's expensive and requires phone reservations, but for those seeking old-world glamour and culinary theatre, Otto's delivers an experience that feels both authentic and extraordinary. This is destination dining for people who appreciate craft, tradition, and the increasingly rare art of genuine hospitality.

Christoff's Rating:

8.7/10

Perfect For:

special occasion diners seeking theatrical fine diningwine enthusiasts interested in Alsatian and French selectionstradition-seekers who appreciate old-school culinary craftsmanship

Otto's Restaurant

Otto's Restaurant

Christoff's Take

Otto's Restaurant: Where Alsatian Theatre Meets Gothic Romance

My Honest Review

Atmosphere & Ambiance

Food & Drink

Service & Experience

Value for Money

Insider Tips

Best Time to Visit

What to Focus On

Christoff's Insider Tips

The Final Verdict

Perfect For:

Quick Details

Otto's Restaurant

What's Great

Keep in Mind

Christoff's Tip:

Vibe check scores

Venue details

Featured In My Guides

Private Dining London: Secret Rooms & Hidden Spaces 2025