Christoff.ai

Kitty Fisher’s

restaurants•
London
London

Kitty Fisher’s

10 Shepherd Market, Mayfair, London W1J 7QF, United Kingdom

Interactive map
Christoff

Christoff's Take

Insider review

Tucked away in a Georgian townhouse on historic Shepherd Market, Kitty Fisher's has mastered the art of intimate dining theatre. This 40-seat basement restaurant serves modern British cuisine with Spanish accents from a wood-fired grill, creating an atmosphere so conspiratorial and romantic that guests routinely linger for 3-4 hours without realising the time has passed.

Kitty Fisher's: Mayfair's Most Coveted Hidden Dining Room

Where Georgian charm meets wood-fired brilliance in Shepherd Market's secret basement

My Honest Review

Atmosphere & Ambiance

Descending into Kitty Fisher's dimly lit basement feels like entering a private members' club without the membership fee - exactly the 'naughty' and 'sexy' vibe they've cultivated. Rose-velvet banquettes catch the flicker of candlelight whilst the open galley kitchen provides gentle theatre, creating an intimate setting that scores 8.5/10 for sophistication. The space strikes that rare balance between cosy and exclusive, with just enough energy (6.5/10) to feel alive without disrupting conversation. Upstairs, a tiny bar offers 10 walk-in stools and a 10-seat terrace for those lucky enough to snag them. The Georgian architecture provides authentic character, whilst the wood-fired elements add warmth and drama. This isn't a place for large groups - the 2.5/10 social group size score reflects its designed intimacy, making it perfect for couples and close friends seeking meaningful dining experiences.

Food & Drink

The wood-fired grill is the star here, producing the legendary Belted Galloway wing-rib for two at £120 - universally praised as a must-try dish alongside their famous crispy potatoes. The modern British menu showcases Spanish accents through dishes like burrata with hazelnut & lovage, chicken-liver parfait with peach & pecan, and seasonal vegetables that let the wood-fired cooking shine. Signature offerings include whipped cod's roe, lamb cutlets, white asparagus, and lemon tart, with mains ranging £18-30. The flavour-packed food justifies the unhurried pace, designed for lingering rather than rushing. An Old-World wine list spans £27-135 with an average of £46, providing solid options across price points. The Spanish influences complement rather than compete with the British foundation, creating a menu that feels both familiar and exciting.

Service & Experience

The staff embody the restaurant's relaxed sophistication - attentive yet unhurried, perfectly matching the 3-4 hour dining rhythm that defines the experience. Service quality aligns with the intimate setting, with staff who understand that this isn't about quick turnover but creating memorable evenings. The open galley kitchen adds to the relaxed atmosphere, allowing diners to witness the wood-fired cooking process. Flexibility scores 7.0/10, suggesting staff accommodate the natural flow of extended meals without pressure to rush.

Value for Money

With expectations of £65-120 per person including wine and a price level of 4/4, Kitty Fisher's sits firmly in special occasion territory. The set lunch around £28 offers better value, though dinner represents the full experience. For Mayfair standards, particularly given the intimate setting and quality of ingredients like Belted Galloway beef, the pricing feels appropriate rather than exploitative. You're paying for the complete experience - the Georgian setting, wood-fired cooking, intimate atmosphere, and extended dining ritual. The 'date-night-pricing' tag is accurate, but the quality of food and uniqueness of the experience (8.0/10 uniqueness score) justify the investment for special occasions.

Insider Tips

Best Time to Visit

Book the 6pm dinner slot weeks in advance for the full experience. Lunch (Wednesday-Saturday 12pm-2:30pm) offers better availability and value. Walk-in bar stools are available at noon and 6:30pm, but extremely limited. Dinner runs Tuesday-Saturday 5:30pm-10pm.

What to Focus On

The legendary Belted Galloway wing-rib for two (£120) with crispy potatoes is essential - this is what Kitty Fisher's is famous for. Start with the chicken-liver parfait with peach & pecan, and don't miss the whipped cod's roe. The lemon tart provides a perfect finish.

Christoff's Insider Tips

Camp those bar stools at 12pm as backup if you can't get a dinner reservation - they're your best shot at experiencing the food without weeks of advance planningThe 'conspiratorial' atmosphere is perfect for important conversations - the 8.5/10 conversation-friendly score isn't accidentalPets are allowed outdoor only, so plan accordingly for the small terrace seating

The Final Verdict

Kitty Fisher's delivers exactly what it promises - an intimate, romantic dining experience that feels both exclusive and welcoming. The wood-fired cooking produces genuinely exceptional food, particularly the famous wing-rib, whilst the Georgian basement setting creates atmosphere that money can't usually buy. Yes, booking is extremely difficult and prices reflect the Mayfair location, but the 3-4 hour experience justifies both the planning and expense. This isn't casual dining - it's dining theatre at its most sophisticated, where the unhurried pace and conspiratorial atmosphere create memories rather than just meals.

Christoff's Rating:
8.7/10

Perfect For:

couples celebrating special occasionsbusiness dinners requiring intimate conversationfood enthusiasts seeking wood-fired British cuisine

Quick Details

1

Kitty Fisher’s

⭐️ Intimate dining
⭐️ Wood fired grill
👑 Mayfair hidden
⭐️ Rose velvet
⭐️ Conspiratorial

This hidden Georgian townhouse in Shepherd Market serves modern British cuisine from a wood-fired grill in an atmosphere that whispers secrets and conspiracy. Rose-velvet banquettes line the dimly lit basement dining room while flickering candles cast shadows across an open galley kitchen. The legendary Belted Galloway wing-rib for two at £120 has achieved cult status, alongside their famous crispy potatoes that arrive golden and impossibly fluffy. The intimate 40-seat space encourages lingering - expect to spend 3-4 hours lost in conversation while attentive staff serve flavor-packed dishes from the wood-fired grill. A tiny upstairs bar offers walk-in stools for the spontaneous, while the basement dining room requires weeks of advance planning. The Old-World wine list ranges from £27-135, and the atmosphere grows more conspiratorial as the evening progresses.

What's Great

✓ Legendary wing-rib and crispy potatoes are universally acclaimed

✓ Intimate Georgian setting perfect for 3-4 hour romantic dinners

Keep in Mind

× Extremely difficult booking process requires weeks of advance planning

Christoff

Christoff's Tip:

Try for bar walk-ins at 12pm or 6:30pm if dinner reservations are impossible

Vibe check scores

Trendiness
Sophistication
Noise Level
Uniqueness

Venue details

🕐"Lunch: Wed-Sat: 12pm-2:30pm\nDinner: Tue-Sat: 5:30pm-10pm"
📍10 Shepherd Market, Mayfair, London W1J 7QF, United Kingdom
💷£££££
📞+44 20 3302 1661
🌐Website

Featured In My Guides

Kitty Fisher’s has been featured in 2 of my curated guides. Here's where you can find more context and discover similar spots.

Mayfair Restaurant Insider: Where Locals Actually Dine 2025 reference image

Mayfair Restaurant Insider: Where Locals Actually Dine 2025

restaurants in london•
Aug 21, 2025
Romance Decoded: London's Secret Date Night Restaurant Map 2025 reference image

Romance Decoded: London's Secret Date Night Restaurant Map 2025

restaurants in london•
Aug 21, 2025
← More restaurants in London← Explore all of London